Thursday, August 20, 2020

How To Spoof PDF Signatures

One year ago, we received a contract as a PDF file. It was digitally signed. We looked at the document - ignoring the "certificate is not trusted" warning shown by the viewer - and asked ourselfs:

"How do PDF signatures exactly work?"

We are quite familiar with the security of message formats like XML and JSON. But nobody had an idea, how PDFs really work. So we started our research journey.

Today, we are happy to announce our results. In this blog post, we give an overview how PDF signatures work and on top, we reveal three novel attack classes for spoofing a digitally signed PDF document. We present our evaluation of 22 different PDF viewers and show 21 of them to be vulnerable. We additionally evaluated 8 online validation services and found 6 to be vulnerable.

In cooperation with the BSI-CERT, we contacted all vendors, provided proof-of-concept exploits, and helped them to fix the issues and three generic CVEs for each attack class were issued: CVE-2018-16042CVE-2018-18688CVE-2018-18689.

Full results are available in the master thesis of Karsten Meyer zu Selhausen, in our security report, and on our website.

Digitally Signed PDFs? Who the Hell uses this?

Maybe you asked yourself, if signed PDFs are important and who uses them.
In fact, you may have already used them.
Have you ever opened an Invoice by companies such as Amazon, Sixt, or Decathlon?
These PDFs are digitally signed and protected against modifications.
In fact, PDF signatures are widely deployed in our world. In 2000, President Bill Clinton enacted a federal law facilitating the use of electronic and digital signatures in interstate and foreign commerce by ensuring the validity and legal effect of contracts. He approved the eSign Act by digitally signing it.
Since 2014, organizations delivering public digital services in an EU member state are required to support digitally signed documents, which are even admissible as evidence in legal proceedings.
In Austria, every governmental authority digitally signs any official document [§19]. In addition, any new law is legally valid after its announcement within a digitally signed PDF.
Several countries like Brazil, Canada, the Russian Federation, and Japan also use and accept digitally signed documents.
According to Adobe Sign, the company processed 8 billion electronic and digital signatures in the 2017 alone.

Crash Course: PDF and PDF Signatures

To understand how to spoof PDF Signatures, we unfortunately need to explain the basics first. So here is a breef overview.

PDF files are ASCII files. You can use a common text editor to open them and read the source code.

PDF header. The header is the first line within a PDF and defines the interpreter version to be used. The provided example uses version PDF 1.7. 
PDF body. The body defines the content of the PDF and contains text blocks, fonts, images, and metadata regarding the file itself. The main building blocks within the body are objects. Each object starts with an object number followed by a generation number. The generation number should be incremented if additional changes are made to the object.
In the given example, the Body contains four objects: Catalog, Pages, Page, and stream. The Catalog object is the root object of the PDF file. It defines the document structure and can additionally declare access permissions. The Catalog refers to a Pages object which defines the number of the pages and a reference to each Page object (e.g., text columns). The Page object contains information how to build a single page. In the given example, it only contains a single string object "Hello World!".
Xref table. The Xref table contains information about the position (byte offset) of all PDF objects within the file.
Trailer. After a PDF file is read into memory, it is processed from the end to the beginning. By this means, the Trailer is the first processed content of a PDF file. It contains references to the Catalog and the Xref table.

How do PDF Signatures work?

PDF Signatures rely on a feature of the PDF specification called incremental saving (also known as incremental update), allowing the modification of a PDF file without changing the previous content.
As you can see in the figure on the left side, the original document is the same document as the one described above. By signing the document, an incremental saving is applied and the following content is added: a new Catalog, a Signature object, a new Xref table referencing the new object(s), and a new Trailer. The new Catalog extends the old one by adding a reference to the Signature object. The Signature object (5 0 obj) contains information regarding the applied cryptographic algorithms for hashing and signing the document. It additionally includes a Contents parameter containing a hex-encoded PKCS7 blob, which holds the certificates as well as the signature value created with the private key corresponding to the public key stored in the certificate. The ByteRange parameter defines which bytes of the PDF file are used as the hash input for the signature calculation and defines 2 integer tuples: 
a, b : Beginning at byte offset a, the following b bytes are used as the first input for the hash calculation. Typically, a 0 is used to indicate that the beginning of the file is used while a b is the byte offset where the PKCS#7 blob begins.
c, d : Typically, byte offset c is the end of the PKCS#7 blob, while c d points to the last byte range of the PDF file and is used as the second input to the hash calculation.
    According to the specification, it is recommended to sign the whole file except for the PKCS#7 blob (located in the range between a b and c).


    During our research, we discovered three novel attack classes on PDF signatures:

    1. Universal Signature Forgery (USF)
    2. Incremental Saving Attack (ISA)
    3. Signature Wrapping Attack (SWA)

    In this blog post, we give an overview on the attacks without going into technical details. If you are more interested, just take a look at the sources we summarized for you here.

    Universal Signature Forgery (USF)

    The main idea of Universal Signature Forgery (USF) is to manipulate the meta information in the signature in such a way that the targeted viewer application opens the PDF file, finds the signature, but is unable to find all necessary data for its validation.

    Instead of treating the missing information as an error, it shows that the contained signature is valid. For example, the attacker can manipulate the Contents or ByteRange values within the Signature object. The manipulation of these entries is reasoned by the fact that we either remove the signature value or the information stating which content is signed.
    The attack seems trivial, but even very good implementations like Adobe Reader DC preventing all other attacks were susceptible against USF.

    Incremental Saving Attack (ISA)

    The Incremental Saving Attack (ISA) abuses a legitimate feature of the PDF specification, which allows to update a PDF file by appending the changes. The feature is used, for example, to store PDF annotations, or to add new pages while editing the file.

    The main idea of the ISA is to use the same technique for changing elements, such as texts, or whole pages included in the signed PDF file to what the attacker desires.
    In other words, an attacker can redefine the document's structure and content using the Body Updates part. The digital signature within the PDF file protects precisely the part of the file defined in the ByteRange. Since the incremental saving appends the Body Updates to the end of the file, it is not part of the defined ByteRange and thus not part of the signature's integrity protection. Summarized, the signature remains valid, while the Body Updates changed the displayed content.
    This is not forbidden by the PDF specification, but the signature validation should indicate that the document has been altered after signing.

    Signature Wrapping Attack (SWA)

    Independently of the PDFs, the main idea behind Signature Wrapping Attacks is to force the verification logic to process different data than the application logic.

    In PDF files, SWA targets the signature validation logic by relocating the originally signed content to a different position within the document and inserting new content at the allocated position. The starting point for the attack is the manipulation of the ByteRange value allowing to shift the signed content to different loctions within the file.

    On a very technical level, the attacker uses a validly signed document (shown on the left side) and proceeds as follows:

    • Step 1 (optional): The attacker deletes the padded zero Bytes within the Contents parameter to increase the available space for injecting manipulated objects.
    • Step 2: The attacker defines a new /ByteRange [a b c* d] by manipulating the c value, which now points to the second signed part placed on a different position within the document.
    • Step 3: The attacker creates a new Xref table pointing to the new objects. It is essential that the byte offset of the newly inserted Xref table has the same byte offset as the previous Xref table. The position is not changeable since it is refer- enced by the signed Trailer. For this purpose, the attacker can add a padding block (e.g., using whitespaces) before the new Xref table to fill the unused space.
    • Step 4: The attacker injects malicious objects which are not protected by the signature. There are different injection points for these objects. They can be placed before or after the malicious Xref table. If Step 1 is not executed, it is only possible to place them after the malicious Xref table.
    • Step 5 (optional): Some PDF viewers need a Trailer after the manipulated Xref table, otherwise they cannot open the PDF file or detect the manipulation and display a warning message. Copying the last Trailer is sufficient to bypass this limitation.
    • Step 6: The attacker moves the signed content defined by c and d at byte offset c*. Optionally, the moved content can be encapsulated within a stream object. Noteworthy is the fact that the manipulated PDF file does not end with %%EOF after the endstream. The reason why some validators throw a warning that the file was manipulated after signing is because of an %%EOF after the signed one. To bypass this requirement, the PDF file is not correctly closed. However, it will be still processed by any viewer.


    In our evaluation, we searched for desktop applications validating digitally signed PDF files. We analyzed the security of their signature validation process against our 3 attack classes. The 22 applications fulfill these requirements. We evaluated the latest versions of the applications on all supported platforms (Windows, MacOS, and Linux).

    Authors of this Post

    Vladislav Mladenov
    Christian Mainka
    Karsten Meyer zu Selhausen
    Martin Grothe
    Jörg Schwenk


    Many thanks to the CERT-Bund team for the great support during the responsible disclosure.
    We also want to acknowledge the teams which reacted to our report and fixed the vulnerable implementations.

    Continue reading
    1. Pentest Automation Tools
    2. Hack Tools Download
    3. Hacking Tools Pc
    4. What Is Hacking Tools
    5. Growth Hacker Tools
    6. Hack Tool Apk No Root
    7. Hacking Tools Usb
    8. How To Make Hacking Tools
    9. Pentest Tools Url Fuzzer
    10. Hacker Tools
    11. Hacking Tools Hardware
    12. Hacking Tools For Games
    13. Hacker Tools Online
    14. World No 1 Hacker Software
    15. Hacking Apps
    16. Hack Tools For Games
    17. Pentest Automation Tools
    18. Hacks And Tools
    19. New Hack Tools
    20. Hacking Tools Software
    21. Hack Tool Apk No Root
    22. How To Install Pentest Tools In Ubuntu
    23. Pentest Tools Find Subdomains
    24. Blackhat Hacker Tools
    25. Ethical Hacker Tools
    26. Ethical Hacker Tools
    27. Hack Tools Download
    28. Pentest Tools Open Source
    29. Underground Hacker Sites
    30. Hacking Tools Windows 10
    31. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
    32. Physical Pentest Tools
    33. Pentest Tools Website
    34. Pentest Tools Review
    35. Hack Tools Mac
    36. Kik Hack Tools
    37. Free Pentest Tools For Windows
    38. Hacking Tools For Games
    39. Hacking Tools For Pc
    40. Hacker Tools Github
    41. Hacker Tools Apk
    42. Pentest Tools Windows
    43. Hacking Tools For Beginners
    44. Hacking Tools Free Download
    45. Hack Tools
    46. Pentest Tools Download
    47. Hack Rom Tools
    48. Hacker Tools For Ios
    49. Hacker Tools
    50. Pentest Tools Download
    51. Hacker Tools For Pc
    52. Hacker Tools Windows
    53. Tools For Hacker
    54. Hacking Tools For Windows Free Download
    55. Tools For Hacker
    56. Hacking Tools Hardware
    57. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
    58. Hacking Tools And Software
    59. Pentest Tools Android
    60. Best Pentesting Tools 2018
    61. Pentest Tools Download
    62. Hacker Tools 2019
    63. Hacker Tools Online
    64. Underground Hacker Sites
    65. Ethical Hacker Tools
    66. Pentest Tools Free
    67. Bluetooth Hacking Tools Kali
    68. Pentest Tools Linux
    69. Pentest Tools Subdomain
    70. Hacking Tools Windows 10
    71. Hacker Tools For Ios
    72. Hack Tools For Mac
    73. Hacking Tools Name
    74. Pentest Tools For Windows
    75. Hacking Tools For Games
    76. Hacking Tools Github
    77. How To Make Hacking Tools
    78. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
    79. Best Hacking Tools 2019
    80. Best Hacking Tools 2020
    81. Hacking Tools Software
    82. Hack Tools Download
    83. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
    84. Hack Tool Apk No Root
    85. Computer Hacker
    86. Hacker Tool Kit
    87. Hacking App
    88. World No 1 Hacker Software
    89. Hacking Tools 2020
    90. Hacker Tools Free
    91. Physical Pentest Tools
    92. Pentest Tools Free
    93. Install Pentest Tools Ubuntu
    94. Hacking Tools Online
    95. Best Hacking Tools 2019
    96. Game Hacking
    97. Pentest Tools For Mac
    98. What Is Hacking Tools
    99. Hacker Tools Free
    100. Hacker Tools Linux
    101. Hack Tool Apk No Root
    102. How To Make Hacking Tools
    103. Hacking Tools Software
    104. Github Hacking Tools
    105. Hack Tools For Games
    106. Pentest Tools Alternative
    107. Hacker Tools Github
    108. Pentest Tools For Mac
    109. Hacking Tools And Software
    110. Pentest Tools Nmap
    111. Usb Pentest Tools
    112. Hack Tools
    113. Hacker Tools For Pc
    114. Hack Tools Pc
    115. Hack Tools For Pc
    116. Hack Tools Online
    117. Android Hack Tools Github
    118. Hack Tools For Pc
    119. Kik Hack Tools
    120. Bluetooth Hacking Tools Kali
    121. How To Make Hacking Tools
    122. Best Hacking Tools 2019
    123. Hacker Tools Free Download
    124. Hacker Tool Kit
    125. Best Pentesting Tools 2018
    126. Kik Hack Tools
    127. Hacks And Tools
    128. Pentest Tools Open Source
    129. Hack Tools Download
    130. Game Hacking
    131. Hacking Tools For Mac
    132. Pentest Tools Website
    133. Pentest Recon Tools
    134. Pentest Tools For Windows
    135. Pentest Tools Framework
    136. Pentest Automation Tools
    137. Pentest Tools List
    138. Hack Rom Tools
    139. Hacker Techniques Tools And Incident Handling
    140. Hacking Tools
    141. Hack Rom Tools
    142. Hacking Tools
    143. Hacking Tools Usb
    144. Pentest Tools For Windows
    145. Hacking Tools Kit
    146. Hackers Toolbox
    147. Hacking Tools For Windows Free Download
    148. Hack Tools Pc
    149. Hack Tools Pc
    150. Pentest Tools Url Fuzzer
    151. Pentest Tools Apk
    152. Hacker Tools 2020
    153. Hacking Tools Windows 10
    154. Hacker Tools Windows
    155. Pentest Tools For Mac
    156. Hacker Tools For Ios
    157. Hacker Tools 2019
    158. Hack Tools For Mac
    159. Hacker Tools Github
    160. Nsa Hack Tools Download
    161. Hacker Tools Windows
    162. Hacking Tools For Kali Linux
    163. Computer Hacker
    164. Hack Tool Apk No Root
    165. Hacker
    166. Hacking Tools Windows 10
    167. Hacker Tools Apk Download
    168. Pentest Tools Port Scanner


    Post a Comment


    Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites